FINAL EYE

How FINAL EYE tests AI video

Every test compares AI video models, or versions of the same model, on the same prompt. The formats change from test to test; the rubric and the blind judging stay fixed.

Updated 19 Nov 2026

The process

Four steps, every test

  1. Fixed rubric

    Prompt adherence /100 plus craft axes, set before any clip is seen.

  2. Blind letters

    Clips are judged as A, B, C… The model names are revealed only after scoring.

  3. Frame-level proof

    Every defect is timecoded and located in the FINAL EYE comparison app.

  4. Human in the loop

    In Test01 P1 the app's automatic scan missed two slight camera pans; the human eye caught them.

Tested via Higgsfield, first generation, no retries.

The rubric

Nine axes

Adherence is scored /100 against the prompt's own words. Execution is the average of axes 3–8. Audio is scored separately.

  • 1
    Prompt & brief adherence/100
  • 2
    Reference fidelity & identity/10
  • 3
    Visual integrity & material credibility/10 · EXEC
  • 4
    Light, colour & art direction/10 · EXEC
  • 5
    Motion, physics & causality/10 · EXEC
  • 6
    Temporal stability & scene continuity/10 · EXEC
  • 7
    Camera & optical execution/10 · EXEC
  • 8
    Performance & expression/10 · EXEC
  • 9
    Audio & audiovisual coherence/10

The tool

The tool

Built in-house for this work; not for sale.

  • Synced timeline with up to four playheads on the same frame.
  • Wipe, split, overlay and difference views.
  • Pixel zoom.
  • RGB parade and BT.709 vectorscope with a probe.
  • Automatic scan for flicker, frozen frames, drift and legal levels.
  • A marker per defect with timecode, severity and axis.

Independence

No sponsors on verdicts

  • No affiliate links on verdicts or rankings.
  • Rubric fixed before each test.
  • No vendor sponsors in the same test.
  • Any commission is disclosed at the top of the page where it applies.

Free report

The free P1 report

See the method on a real test: the Test01 P1 report, sent by email when you subscribe to the FINAL EYE newsletter.