FINAL EYE

Skin Under Mixed Light

Gemini Omni Flash 1.2 vs Wan 3.0 vs MiniMax H3 vs Kling 4.0 vs Seedance 2.5 · Nov 2026

Updated 19 Nov 20265 modelsSame prompt · first generation · no retriesVia Higgsfield

The answer · 19 Nov 2026

As of 19 Nov 2026, in a blind FINAL EYE test of one close-up under mixed light, Gemini Omni Flash 1.2 rendered the most believable skin (execution 7.42/10, adherence 78.1/100). Wan 3.0 came second (6.67/10, 77/100). MiniMax H3 scored 6.17, Kling 4.0 5.75 and Seedance 2.5 5.67 on execution. No model made raindrop shadows crawl across the face, the hardest trap in the prompt. Every defect is logged with a timecode.

Final pick

AGemini Omni Flash 1.2

Execution 7.42/10 · adherence 78.1/100

See the scores ↓

The prompt

One close-up, five models

An intimate close-up at eye level: a woman in her mid-40s at a café table by a rain-streaked window at night, fixed frame, 85mm at T2.
A warm 2700K table lamp camera-left, cyan-green neon through the wet glass camera-right, moving raindrop shadows on her face, about 4:1 contrast, real skin with pores and fine lines.

Same prompt for every model · 16:9 · 720p · 8 s · first generation, no retries · tested via Higgsfield.

  • Gemini Omni Flash 1.2
  • Wan 3.0
  • Kling 4.0
  • MiniMax H3
  • Seedance 2.5

Scores

Ranking

Adherence scores how closely each clip follows the prompt's own words, out of 100. Execution is the average of the six craft axes, out of 10. The final ranking weighs what a viewer accepts on screen: Kling 4.0 moves up to third because its dark background hides its artefacts, and MiniMax H3 drops to fourth because its colours are hard to accept.

#ClipAdherenceExecAudioTech
1AGemini Omni Flash 1.278.1/1007.42/106.58.5
2EWan 3.077.0/1006.67/10N/A7.5 (30 fps)
3BKling 4.060.5/1005.75/106.010
4CMiniMax H374.5/1006.17/104.58.5
5DSeedance 2.570.0/1005.67/10N/A9.5

Final pick: Gemini Omni Flash 1.2. Every defect is logged with a timecode. How the scores work →

Findings

What FINAL EYE found

Four defects that decide the ranking, each shown at its frame.

Clip A, Gemini Omni Flash 1.2, raindrop shadows stretched too far across the cheek, circled, 00:00:03:20
MajorAxis 5 · MotionClip A00:00:03:20

Raindrop shadows

During the turn the raindrop shadows re-form on her face as it moves through them, but stretch too far across her cheek, beyond what the change of angle explains. The prompt asked for raindrop shadows crawling across her face. No model delivered it.

Clip B, Kling 4.0, medium shot instead of the requested close-up, lamp in frame lights nothing, circled, 00:00:05:00
MajorClip B00:00:05:00

Lamp

Asked for an intimate close-up, Kling 4.0 delivers a medium shot, and the lamp in frame lights nothing.

Clip C, MiniMax H3, skin hue off on both cheeks, orange on the interior side and oversaturated green on the window side, 00:00:03:06
MajorClip C00:00:03:06

Skin hue

Skin hues off on both sides: the interior side pushed too orange, the window side oversaturated green.

Clip D, Seedance 2.5, lamp reflection in the window sharper than the lamp itself, circled, 00:00:01:16
MajorClip D00:00:01:16

Reflection

The lamp's reflection is slightly sharper than the lamp itself, which is physically impossible. Caught by eye, frame by frame.

Measurements

Contrast, continuity, delivery

Contrast measured from lit cheek to shadow cheek against the 4:1 the prompt asked for, plus continuity and technical delivery.

ModelContrast, lit cheek to shadow cheek (asked: 4:1)
Seedance 2.5~4.5:1
MiniMax H3~3–3.6:1
Gemini Omni Flash 1.2~10:1
Kling 4.0~60–80:1
Wan 3.0~1.8:1
  • Technical delivery: Wan delivers 30 fps where 24 was asked.
  • Continuity: car continuity breaks in Wan and MiniMax.
Contrast measured from lit cheek to shadow cheek in all five clips against the 4:1 the prompt asked for
Major for Kling and WanAll five clips

Contrast

Measured against the 4:1 the prompt asked for: Seedance ~4.5:1, MiniMax ~3–3.6:1, Gemini ~10:1, Kling ~60–80:1, Wan ~1.8:1.

Clip E, Wan 3.0, three identical evenly spaced lines at the corner of the mouth, circled, 00:00:05:11
MajorClip E00:00:05:11

Mouth

Three identical, evenly spaced lines at the corner of the mouth: a generation artefact a client spots on a close-up.

Clip D, Seedance 2.5, raindrop shadows rendered as a net-like mesh on the face, circled, 00:00:03:11
MajorClip D00:00:03:11

Raindrop shadows

The raindrop shadows look like macramé, a net-like mesh with large openings, nothing like the droplets on the glass.

Human in the loop

The eye beat the automatic scan

The app's automatic scan missed two slight camera pans, in Seedance and Wan. The human eye caught them. No model matched the 85mm look either: every clip reads wider, from 24mm to 60mm.

The FINAL EYE comparison app: synced split view with timecoded defect markers on each clip timeline, letters only

The FINAL EYE comparison app: synced split view, frame stepping, timecoded defect markers on every clip's timeline. Letters only; model names blurred.

How FINAL EYE tests AI video →

The clips

Watch and download the clips

All five clips, as generated, to watch and download. Check every finding yourself.

Clip A, Gemini Omni Flash 1.2: frame from Test01 P1Clip E, Wan 3.0: frame from Test01 P1Clip B, Kling 4.0: frame from Test01 P1Clip C, MiniMax H3: frame from Test01 P1Clip D, Seedance 2.5: frame from Test01 P1

Reports

The free P1 report

The P1 report: verdict, scorecard and the major defects per model, free by email.

FreeTest01 P1 report

Sent by email when you subscribe to the FINAL EYE newsletter.

Test01 P1: Complete Edition

Everything the free summary leaves out: every defect, with its frame; the scores on every axis, each with its reason; the prompt-adherence questionnaire; the full prompt with its traps; the comparison log; the technical delivery and broadcast-standards checks; and the defect list as a CSV. PDF (78 pages) + CSV, pay what you want, from $9.

ComingFull Test01 report (P1–P4)

Available when all four prompts are judged. Subscribers get notified.

Shipping AI video to a client? AI video QA from $35 per clip: timecoded defects with location and severity, and what to regenerate.

Book a review →

Case study: Skin Under Mixed Light: AI Video Test on Behance

No vendor affiliation. Reports signed by Răzvan Ioniță, cinematographer and colorist.